Programming That Makes Members Proud to Invite Guests
START HERE
If you only do one thing this week:
Ask 3 members "Would you confidently invite a colleague to next week's program? Why or why not?"
If you do two things:
Add that question + allocate even $500 for one flagship speaker in the next quarter
If you want the full system:
Read on for the complete program excellence framework
Introduction
You'll never solve your membership problem until you solve your programming problem.
Here's why: In most service clubs, the weekly program IS the product. If it's strong, members invite guests. If it's weak, they stop.
The compound effect works both ways. One great speaker generates conversations for weeks and referrals for months. One embarrassing speaker makes members hesitate to invite anyone for weeks.
The "embarrassed host phenomenon" is real: You invite a potential member, the speaker is dull or unprepared, and you spend the drive home apologizing. That colleague probably won't return, and you'll hesitate to invite others.
This guide breaks down how to build a sustainable program excellence system—one that makes members proud to invite guests and confident that their time investment will pay off.
Why Programming Is Your
Growth Engine
The math is simple:
40-50 meetings per year (accounting for holidays)
•
If 30 are mediocre and 10 are good, what's your brand?
•
Members stop inviting guests when they can't guarantee quality
•
Quality programs create the "you have to come next week" conversations that drive guest visits
What members say privately:
"I'd invite more people, but I never know if the speaker will be good"
•
"Last week's presentation was embarrassing—I won't risk that again"
•
"Our programs used to be better"
What thriving clubs do differently:
They treat program quality as a strategic investment, not a budget line to minimize
The hidden costs of weak programming:
Declining attendance (members skip meetings they expect to be boring)
•
Reduced guest conversion (guests visit once, aren't impressed, don't return)
•
Volunteer burnout (program chairs quit after a year of scrambling)
•
Weak referrals (members don't talk about meetings because there's nothing worth sharing)
The Excellence Standard:
What "Good" Actually Means
Not all speakers are created equal for service club audiences.
What makes a speaker
"good"
for service clubs:
Content:
Substantive (not motivational fluff)
•
Actionable (members can use the insights)
•
Relevant to civic-minded audiences
•
Appropriate length (25-30 minutes, not 45)
Delivery:
Adapted to service club culture (not a corporate keynote copy-paste)
•
Understands meeting flow and customs
•
Respects time boundaries religiously
•
Engages without being theatrical
Preparation:
Researches your specific organization
•
References your community context
•
Asks about your format and expectations
•
Provides clear bio for introduction
The most common
mismatches:
Corporate motivational speakers:
Great for conferences, often wrong for service club lunch meetings
Too polished, not enough substance
Don't understand the fellowship/service context
Sales pitches disguised as presentations:
"Let me tell you about my coaching program/book/service"
Erodes trust with members and embarrasses the program chair
Academic experts who can't translate:
Deep knowledge, poor communication
Talks for 50 minutes because "there's so much to cover"
Loses the room in jargon
The sweet spot speaker:
Practical expertise + authentic delivery + respect for service club culture + strict time discipline
Moving Beyond
"Whoever Will Come For Free"
The false economy of free speakers
Budget constraints are real, but prioritizing cost over quality is expensive in hidden ways
What free speakers often mean:
Sales presentations from financial advisors, insurance agents, real estate agents
•
Retired members telling war stories
•
Whoever responded to your Facebook post asking for speakers
•
Quality varies wildly—some are great, many aren't
What you're really buying with a speaker budget:
You're not paying for a speaker. You're buying the ability for members to invite guests without fear. You're buying confidence that this week's meeting will be worth their time. You're buying referrals that happen in parking lot conversations afterward.
The modest investment approach:
Even a small annual budget set aside for 4-6 flagship programs signals "we value our members' time"
Opens access to professional speakers who understand civic audiences
Still allows free/unpaid speakers (member experts, community leaders, nonprofit directors) for other slots
Alternative budget models:
Annual sponsorship: local business sponsors speaker budget in exchange for recognition
Per-meeting sponsorship: $100 sponsor underwrites that week's program
District speaker fund: collaborate with nearby clubs to share costs
Hybrid: invest in 4-6 flagship programs annually, supplement with quality free speakers
How to Find Speakers
Who Understand
Service Club Culture
The traditional approach (and why it's exhausting):
Google "speakers in [city]"
▼
Cold call/email dozens of people
▼
Hope they understand service club format
▼
Spend hours educating them about your organization
▼
Cross fingers on meeting day
▼
Repeat weekly
The smarter approach: Vet for culture fit first
Questions to ask potential speakers:
"Have you presented to service clubs before? Which organizations?"
•
"What do you know about [Rotary/Kiwanis/Lions/Optimist]?"
•
"Our format is a 25-30 minute presentation during lunch—can you work within that?"
•
"Can you adapt your content to a civic-minded audience?"
Red flags in responses:
"I usually speak for 45-60 minutes" (and no willingness to adapt)
•
"What's Rotary?" (for Rotary clubs—signals zero research)
•
"Can I bring handouts about my services?" (sales pitch incoming)
•
"I'll need A/V, a podium, stage lighting..." (doesn't understand typical venues)
Green flags:
"I've spoken to [specific clubs] and understand your format"
•
"I can adapt my talk to 25 minutes easily"
•
"I'd love to learn about your club's current projects to make this relevant"
•
"What's your typical audience size and demographics?"
Speaker Brief
Template
(copy/paste this):
SPEAKER BRIEF
Audience: [Number] members, mix of [age ranges], [professional backgrounds]
Format: Seated lunch meeting, U-shaped or round tables
Time slot: [Exact time] with hard stop at [time]
Your speaking time: 25 minutes + 5-10 min Q&A
A/V available: [projector/screen OR none]
About our club:
- [Organization name] club serving [community] since [year]
- Current focus: [one major project]
- Mission: [brief statement]
What we're looking for:
Give our members something they can use this week. Practical over theoretical. Authentic over polished. Substance over motivation.
Contact: [Name, phone, email]
This template becomes your standard. Send it to every speaker you're considering.
Leverage existing
resources:
Organization-specific speaker resources: Many service organizations maintain speaker directories—Rotary districts often have lists, Lions Clubs International has speaker resources. Start there.
Cross-club referrals: Ask program chairs in nearby clubs: "Who have you had recently that was exceptional?" Service club program chairs are typically generous with recommendations.
Speaker preparation guides: Rather than educating every speaker from scratch about your organization's culture, look for speakers who've already done that homework. Resources like organization-specific guides help speakers understand service club expectations before they walk in the room—meeting structure, time discipline, audience values.
Local expert networks:
University faculty (often free, usually excellent)
•
Nonprofit executive directors (invested in community, understand civic context)
•
Government officials (city managers, school superintendents)
•
Published authors with local ties
•
Retired executives with specialized knowledge
Build your own referral network:
When you find a great speaker, ask them: "Who else do you know who presents to groups like ours?" Quality speakers know other quality speakers.
The Program Chair
Support System
Why program chairs quit:
Overwhelming weekly responsibility with no tools
•
Zero budget and expected to book quality speakers
•
Lack of appreciation when things go well, blamed when they don't
•
No guidance on how to evaluate or vet speakers
Set up your
Program Chair
for success:
Resources:
Speaker database access (organizational, local, or curated)
•
Email templates for speaker outreach
•
Standard speaker information form (bio, A/V needs, topic, timing)
•
Introduction template (so you're not writing from scratch weekly)
•
Feedback form for members to evaluate programs
Budget:
Even a modest, consistent speaker budget makes an enormous difference in program chair's ability to book quality.
Support:
Backup: Assistant program chair or committee to share load
•
Regular check-ins: President meets monthly with program chair
•
Lead time: Start booking 3-6 months out, not week-to-week scrambling
Recognition:
This is a strategic position. Treat it accordingly in your leadership structure.
Term length:
Consider 6-month or 1-year terms with clear succession planning. Asking someone to do this role for years with no support is how you get declining program quality.
Beyond Weekly Speakers:
Diverse Programming Models
Variety keeps engagement high.
Member spotlight series:
Quarterly (not too often)
•
Member presents on their expertise or passion
•
20 minutes + Q&A
•
Builds internal connection, often reveals hidden talents
Panel discussions:
3-4 local leaders on a community topic
•
Moderated Q&A format
•
Great for: local elections, community development, education policy
•
Members get to participate by asking questions
Interactive workshops:
Replace speaker with working session
•
Examples: grant writing basics, social media for nonprofits, public speaking practice
•
Members develop skills while networking
Community leader Q&A:
Mayor, school superintendent, police chief, hospital administrator
•
Less formal presentation, more dialogue
•
Positions your club as civically engaged
Service project planning meetings:
Once a quarter, dedicate meeting time to upcoming project logistics
•
Gets members engaged in the work itself
•
Programming doesn't always need external content
Virtual options:
High-profile speakers via Zoom who couldn't attend in person
•
TEDx-style: watch 15-minute video, then facilitated discussion
•
Hybrid: some members in room, others remote
The Quality Control
Feedback Loop
Simple feedback system:
Post-program survey (optional, monthly):
Scale of 1-5: "How valuable was today's program?"
•
Open: "What made it valuable/not valuable?"
•
"Would you recommend this speaker to another club?"
Or simpler: informal check-ins: Program chair asks 3-4 members after each meeting: "What did you think?"
Track over time:
Which topics generate most engagement?
Which speakers get invited back?
Correlation between program quality and attendance?
Use data:
Double down on what works (topic types, speaker styles)
Eliminate what consistently falls flat
Share great speakers with other clubs (builds goodwill)
The Time Discipline
Non-Negotiable
This is sacred in service club culture.
Why it matters so much:
Members have obligations before and after meetings
•
Going over time signals disrespect
•
It's the fastest way to kill member satisfaction
How to enforce:
Before the meeting:
Confirm time limit with speaker (in writing)
"You'll have 25 minutes for your talk, then 5-10 minutes for Q&A"
During the meeting:
Visible timer or signal person
•
5-minute warning (note card, subtle signal)
•
Wrap at 30 minutes, firmly
If speaker runs over:
President politely interrupts: "I'm sorry to cut in, but we're at time—let's open for a few quick questions"
•
Thank them graciously but don't let it continue
Communication to members:
"We respect your time" should be a brand promise you deliver on every week.
Conclusion
Programming quality is the growth engine most clubs undervalue. When your programs are consistently good, members invite guests confidently. When they're inconsistent or mediocre, members stop inviting anyone.
The fix isn't complicated: modest budget, systematic speaker vetting, program chair support, and absolute time discipline.
You can't grow your club by working on membership alone. You have to work on the experience that makes membership valuable.
Start with one improvement: allocate even a small speaker budget, or implement a speaker vetting checklist, or survey members about program quality. Build from there.
Related:
The Guest Experience Audit — Because program quality is just one part of guest experience
Organization-Specific Guides — Help your speakers prepare for your club's culture
The 3-Minute Connection — Share this with speakers you book
